Alright everyone, the mystery has been SOLVED!
I followed Tim's advice and installed a KOSO temp gauge and found out my van is running 175 - 190! Even after installing an OEM temperature sending unit, my gauge is way off. Looks like I'll be relying on the new gauge instead of my stock gauge.
I can also rest assured that I now have an all new cooling system . Looks like I'm ready to head to Key West in April for the first major trip.
Thank you all again for the generous help.
-Hugh